Most Overrated vs Underrated VPNs — Community Vote: 5 Picks That Actually Save You Money

1️⃣Mullvad VPN

Mullvad is the underrated community favorite for ruthless simplicity and real privacy. Flat pricing, anonymous payment, and fast WireGuard make it a workhorse on every device. If you value privacy over hype, this is the quiet winner.

2️⃣Proton VPN

Proton VPN is the underrated blend of privacy pedigree and daily usability. The free plan is genuinely useful, while paid tiers unlock Secure Core and reliable streaming. It feels premium without the premium headache.

3️⃣ExpressVPN

ExpressVPN is a household name with slick apps and marketing, but often considered overrated by voters. It is fast, but the price keeps climbing and device limits hurt families. You often pay more to get about the same as cheaper rivals.

4️⃣NordVPN

NordVPN is feature packed with strong speeds and a big brand halo, yet some users call it overrated outside of sales. Aggressive upsells and a complex product suite add friction, and support quality can be inconsistent. Great on deep discounts, less compelling at full price.

5️⃣Surfshark

Surfshark is the bargain favorite with unlimited devices and sharp promos, but hype can overshoot reality for power users. It works for casual streaming and travel, yet speeds can fluctuate and sites trigger CAPTCHAs more often. The newer brand history still makes some buyers cautious.