Most Overrated vs Underrated VPNs — Community Vote (the cheap winners we actually buy)

Most Overrated vs Underrated VPNs — Community Vote (the cheap winners we actually buy)

27 November 2025 Views: 0

1️⃣Surfshark

Voters crowned this the most underrated VPN for real-world value. Fast, cheap, and it covers every device in your house. Great for streaming and travel with solid privacy plus ad blocking.

Address: The Hague, Netherlands

  • Unlimited devices on one plan
  • Low long term pricing with frequent deals
  • Very fast WireGuard speeds
  • Unblocks major streaming platforms
  • CleanWeb blocks ads and trackers
  • 24/7 live chat
  • 30 day money back guarantee
  • Fewer specialty servers than some rivals
  • Apps can feel busy for first time users

2️⃣NordVPN

Another community favorite that delivers premium speed without the premium bill on long plans. Packed with useful extras like mesh networking and threat protection while staying easy to use. Strong audits back the no logs stance.

Address: Vilnius, Lithuania

  • Exceptional speed with NordLynx
  • Large server network plus audited no logs policy
  • Unlocks many streaming libraries
  • Meshnet device to device sharing
  • Optional bundle perks for security
  • 24/7 support
  • 30 day money back
  • Bundles can upsell features you may not use
  • Map style UI is not for everyone

3️⃣ExpressVPN

Polished and reliable, but often overrated for the price. You pay more and get fewer connections than value leaders. Best for users who prioritize simplicity over savings.

Address: Road Town, British Virgin Islands

  • Simple apps on every platform
  • Stable performance worldwide
  • Audited privacy practices
  • Good speeds
  • Higher monthly price than most
  • Limited simultaneous connections
  • No built in ad blocker

4️⃣TunnelBear

Friendly and transparent, yet overrated once you need streaming or advanced tools. Great for casual browsing, less so for power users or travelers. Cute brand, limited muscle.

Address: Toronto, Canada

  • Beginner friendly design
  • Annual independent audits
  • Works fine for casual privacy
  • Clear pricing
  • Small server list
  • Streaming unlock hit or miss
  • Few advanced settings
  • Limited country coverage

5️⃣Hotspot Shield

Tempting free plan, but the upgrade path gets expensive fast. Ads, limits, and inconsistent streaming make it feel overrated next to better value rivals. Good for quick installs, not for heavy daily use.

Address: Redwood City, California, USA

  • Fast local speeds
  • Free tier available
  • One click setup
  • Split tunneling on many devices
  • Ads and bandwidth limits on free plan
  • Premium price versus value leaders
  • Proprietary protocol limits flexibility
  • Inconsistent streaming support